Rugby Legends Clash in Martin Johnson's Ultimate XV – But Who Got Left Out?
Imagine the thrill of assembling the most formidable rugby team ever, drawing from decades of heroes who redefined the sport. That's exactly what Martin Johnson, England's legendary World Cup-winning captain, has done in his dream lineup – and it's sparking debates among fans worldwide. But here's where it gets controversial: some all-time greats like Lawrence Dallaglio, Shane Williams, Brian O’Driscoll, and Jason Robinson are noticeably absent. Could this be a bold shake-up of rugby's hall of fame, or a missed opportunity? Stick around as we dive into Johnson's choices and unpack why they might surprise you.
Johnson, the hero who led England to victory in the 2003 Rugby World Cup and captained the British & Irish Lions twice (in 1997 and 2001), has crafted a squad packed with rugby's elite. With two Six Nations Grand Slams to his name (1995 and 2003), he's widely regarded as one of the game's greatest leaders – a player who embodied toughness, strategy, and inspirational command on the field. So, what makes his ultimate XV so intriguing? Let's break it down player by player, with some added context to help newcomers grasp the roles and why these selections stand out.
BACK THREE
Starting at Fullback: Serge Blanco (France). Blanco was a true wizard with the ball, amassing 38 tries in 93 matches for France and dazzling fans with his offensive brilliance. For beginners, the fullback is like the last line of defense and often the spark for attacks, using speed and vision to launch plays.
"He was a phenomenal French fullback who controlled the game," Johnson recalls. Imagine watching a player whose flair could turn a defensive scramble into a scoring opportunity – that's Blanco in a nutshell.
Next up, Winger: Joe Roff (Australia). Roff was integral to Australia's dominant era, helping secure the 1999 Rugby World Cup and notching 30 tries in 86 international matches. He combined blistering speed with clever tactics and exceptional rugby intelligence, making him a versatile threat. Wings are the flankers of the attack, racing down the sidelines for try-scoring finishes, and Roff exemplified this with his all-around skills.
"Sure, you might think of David Campese as the top Aussie winger, but Roff is my pick. He was a brilliant, well-rounded player in the classic style," Johnson explains. This choice highlights how Johnson values a balanced game over raw star power, and it's a point that could divide opinion: is versatility more important than individual flair?
And then there's Winger: Jonah Lomu (New Zealand). Widely considered the most intimidating winger ever, Lomu's 15 Rugby World Cup tries and unstoppable charges revolutionized rugby. His presence alone could shift the momentum of a match, bullying through defenses with sheer power and pace. For those new to the game, wings are the speed demons who finish off moves, and Lomu's impact was so profound that he changed how teams prepare for such threats.
"Picking one of the greatest wings of all time wasn't hard," Johnson says. But here's the part most people miss: Including Lomu alongside Roff creates a backline with contrasting styles – raw power versus tactical finesse – which might just be Johnson's masterstroke for balance.
CENTRES
Moving to Outside-centre: Philippe Sella (France). Sella was the first French player to reach 100 caps and is hailed as one of the most well-rounded centres in history. Centres act as the midfield generals, linking attack and defense, and Sella's completeness made him a nightmare for opponents. His career spanned an era when rugby was evolving, and he adapted brilliantly.
"I grew up watching him on TV and admired him then. Playing against him showed me he was even better – tackling him felt like hitting a brick wall," Johnson shares. This selection underscores Johnson's respect for durability and skill, but could it fuel debates about modern vs. classic rugby? For example, how does Sella compare to today's high-scoring centres?
Finally, Inside-centre: Danie Gerber (South Africa). Despite never playing in a Rugby World Cup due to South Africa's exclusion from international rugby during apartheid, Gerber dazzled with his lightning speed and 19 tries in just 24 Tests. Centres in this position often provide the punch in the middle, using pace to break through defenses, and Gerber's talent shone brightly in limited opportunities.
"Though apartheid limited his Tests, he possessed incredible strength and speed. I faced him in a charity game in 1996 when he was in his 40s, and he was still incredible," Johnson notes. This pick brings a layer of historical context: Gerber's exclusion highlights rugby's past controversies around politics and equality, making Johnson's choice a nod to overlooked legends. And this is where controversy brews – does selecting players from eras of exclusion make the lineup fair, or should only World Cup-tested players qualify?
CONTINUES ON PAGE TWO (https://www.ruck.co.uk/martin-johnson-named-his-greatest-rugby-15-of-all-time/2)
Pages: 12 (https://www.ruck.co.uk/martin-johnson-named-his-greatest-rugby-15-of-all-time/2/) 3 (https://www.ruck.co.uk/martin-johnson-named-his-greatest-rugby-15-of-all-time/3/)
Post navigation
What do you think of Johnson's selections? Are you shocked by the omissions, or do you agree with his bold choices? Does including players like Gerber raise important questions about fairness in sports history? Share your thoughts in the comments – let's debate: Is this the ultimate XV, or just one man's vision?
